Hole in My Life
16 posts
• Page 1 of 2 • 1, 2
Hole in My Life
by NoOneYouKnow on 31 Aug 2007 17:33
Did they change this up at all, or is it more or less the same live version they've done before?
- NoOneYouKnow
- Posts: 80
- Joined: 02 Oct 2006 01:11
by Laz on 31 Aug 2007 18:57
Someone posted on TPT.com that the version they're doing now is in E minor where before it used to be in A minor. Should be very interesting... definitely looking forward to that bootleg...
Laz
ps. ...oh yeah, and that "Hit The Road Jack" tag at the end... (evidently they also used to do that in the Synchronicity tour)
Laz
ps. ...oh yeah, and that "Hit The Road Jack" tag at the end... (evidently they also used to do that in the Synchronicity tour)
-
Laz - Posts: 682
- Joined: 10 Feb 2007 02:39
- Location: Right smack in L.A., too far from Tokyo :(
by NoOneYouKnow on 31 Aug 2007 20:10
Well, aside from a key change, I was wondering if they had come up with a new arrangement for it - a la "Walking In Your Footsteps" or "Invisible Sun" etc.
I s'poze there'd be more talk about it if that were the case though.
Just wondering. Happy to hear it anyway they want to play it.
I s'poze there'd be more talk about it if that were the case though.
Just wondering. Happy to hear it anyway they want to play it.
- NoOneYouKnow
- Posts: 80
- Joined: 02 Oct 2006 01:11
Re: Hole in My Life
by secretjourneyranch on 02 Sep 2007 19:54
[quote="NoOneYouKnow"]Did they change this up at all, or is it more or less the same live version they've done before?[/quote]
Steerpike posted it on dime, and after listening to it, it sounds like a slower more tentative attempt of the Synch tour version. Much lower key and at this point very little excitement to it. 'Hit The Road' tag also. They must've studied one of there own boots such as 'This Must Be Heaven' to get this version. Hopefully after a few more goes at it they will be comfortable enough to speed it up and make it stellar again....overall losing Bed's for this version of Hole is not an even exchange...
Steerpike posted it on dime, and after listening to it, it sounds like a slower more tentative attempt of the Synch tour version. Much lower key and at this point very little excitement to it. 'Hit The Road' tag also. They must've studied one of there own boots such as 'This Must Be Heaven' to get this version. Hopefully after a few more goes at it they will be comfortable enough to speed it up and make it stellar again....overall losing Bed's for this version of Hole is not an even exchange...
-
secretjourneyranch - Posts: 400
- Joined: 01 Jun 2006 00:41
- Location: Texas
by DirtyMartini on 02 Sep 2007 21:12
I heart Dan.
And I heart Stewart and Andy! Fun! Aside from Sting's irksome phrasings, the only thing I don't like are the "yeah"s. Somehow I feel like they either need to be really punched out or not done at all cuz doing them in a languid fashion just doesn't fit well with the rest of the sound. And the big pause-y ending is crying for Sting to say something (such as the ol' "one time for me" bit -- but *something*). Particularly once it's more familiar, I think it'll be a pretty good burst of energy.
And I heart Stewart and Andy! Fun! Aside from Sting's irksome phrasings, the only thing I don't like are the "yeah"s. Somehow I feel like they either need to be really punched out or not done at all cuz doing them in a languid fashion just doesn't fit well with the rest of the sound. And the big pause-y ending is crying for Sting to say something (such as the ol' "one time for me" bit -- but *something*). Particularly once it's more familiar, I think it'll be a pretty good burst of energy.
Dramatic highlights & a unique musical cosmos. Guaranteed.
-
DirtyMartini - Posts: 9622
- Joined: 03 Mar 2007 18:38
- Location: Around.
by Laz on 03 Sep 2007 01:50
[quote="DirtyMartini"]I heart Dan.
And I heart Stewart and Andy! Fun! Aside from Sting's irksome phrasings, the only thing I don't like are the "yeah"s. Somehow I feel like they either need to be really punched out or not done at all cuz doing them in a languid fashion just doesn't fit well with the rest of the sound. And the big pause-y ending is crying for Sting to say something (such as the ol' "one time for me" bit -- but *something*). Particularly once it's more familiar, I think it'll be a pretty good burst of energy.[/quote]
Listening to it now (Stockholm 8/30 boot)... I like it... a bit on the slow side, sure, but so were Truth Hits Everybody and DSSCTM and some others from the beginning of the tour, so I would imagine if they continue doing this one eventually it will speed up... I do agree that the "yeah"s are drawn out and vibrato'd a bit much almost... you sense that any moment Sting's going to lapse into a rather polite "yes"... but overall I think it sounds good... that ol' Stewart Hole In My Life shuffle pocket certainly hasn't disappeared, that's for sure... Andy's smokin' on it... yeah, I like it... as for Bed's Too Big, well, I did manage to see them do that one 6 times at 6 different shows, so I'm not complaining...
Laz
And I heart Stewart and Andy! Fun! Aside from Sting's irksome phrasings, the only thing I don't like are the "yeah"s. Somehow I feel like they either need to be really punched out or not done at all cuz doing them in a languid fashion just doesn't fit well with the rest of the sound. And the big pause-y ending is crying for Sting to say something (such as the ol' "one time for me" bit -- but *something*). Particularly once it's more familiar, I think it'll be a pretty good burst of energy.[/quote]
Listening to it now (Stockholm 8/30 boot)... I like it... a bit on the slow side, sure, but so were Truth Hits Everybody and DSSCTM and some others from the beginning of the tour, so I would imagine if they continue doing this one eventually it will speed up... I do agree that the "yeah"s are drawn out and vibrato'd a bit much almost... you sense that any moment Sting's going to lapse into a rather polite "yes"... but overall I think it sounds good... that ol' Stewart Hole In My Life shuffle pocket certainly hasn't disappeared, that's for sure... Andy's smokin' on it... yeah, I like it... as for Bed's Too Big, well, I did manage to see them do that one 6 times at 6 different shows, so I'm not complaining...
Laz
-
Laz - Posts: 682
- Joined: 10 Feb 2007 02:39
- Location: Right smack in L.A., too far from Tokyo :(
by DirtyMartini on 03 Sep 2007 04:42
[quote="Laz"]a bit on the slow side, sure, but so were Truth Hits Everybody and DSSCTM and some others from the beginning of the tour, so I would imagine if they continue doing this one eventually it will speed up...[/quote]
Exactly my thinking, so I didn't pay it much mind.
[quote="Laz"]I do agree that the "yeah"s are drawn out and vibrato'd a bit much almost... you sense that any moment Sting's going to lapse into a rather polite "yes"...[/quote]
HA! Very well put, Laz.
Exactly my thinking, so I didn't pay it much mind.
[quote="Laz"]I do agree that the "yeah"s are drawn out and vibrato'd a bit much almost... you sense that any moment Sting's going to lapse into a rather polite "yes"...[/quote]
HA! Very well put, Laz.
Dramatic highlights & a unique musical cosmos. Guaranteed.
-
DirtyMartini - Posts: 9622
- Joined: 03 Mar 2007 18:38
- Location: Around.
by samburusunset on 03 Sep 2007 07:06
Took a listen. Eh, basically what everyone else said. Needs polishing.
Pick up the speed in the next week, boys!!
Pick up the speed in the next week, boys!!
Stewart and Stanley together again!! YO!
-
samburusunset - Posts: 5012
- Joined: 07 Mar 2007 19:28
- Location: Day dreaming of Italy
by Lynne on 04 Sep 2007 01:26
[quote="DirtyMartini"] Somehow I feel like they either need to be really punched out or not done at all cuz doing them in a languid fashion just doesn't fit well with the rest of the sound.[/quote]
As is her wont, DM has hit on the precise word for which I've been struggling as I think about my problems with some of the rearrangements: languid. I'd love it if they can pull off the combination of lower key, tension, and urgency; the languid pace saps the tension and urgency that I think is crucial to songs like, for example, Don't Stand So Close To Me.
As is her wont, DM has hit on the precise word for which I've been struggling as I think about my problems with some of the rearrangements: languid. I'd love it if they can pull off the combination of lower key, tension, and urgency; the languid pace saps the tension and urgency that I think is crucial to songs like, for example, Don't Stand So Close To Me.
... trained by the CIA to accept vast quantities of information at high speed in binary code
-
Lynne - Posts: 1544
- Joined: 11 Jul 2007 22:49
- Location: "Forty-something now, but still looking pretty good."
16 posts
• Page 1 of 2 • 1, 2
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 7 guests