I finally wrote up my full review. (insert shameless link promotion here):
http://www.spacial-anomaly.com/circa-ze ... unds-like/
Overall I have to say after repeated listens I'm definitely in the "I like it" camp and not "I love it". Some of the problem is I just don't especially care for Giles' singing (it IS at times like Bono, and that's a problem from my point of view. I can't stand Bono's singing, it's like nails on a chalkboard to me.) The lyrics don't grab me and some of them I could only understand thanks to the bonus acoustic tracks. I don't mind the Police similarities in sound and in fact certainly would expect nothing less, at least not when it comes to the guitar work. It's just that it overall feels and sounds very derivative and not unique enough; I keep thinking "wow this song reminds me of... (insert band name here)" instead of feeling like it sounds like something new and fresh and distinct -- and that I want to hear more of it.