by DirtyMartini on 13 Aug 2009 18:43
[quote="TheEqualizer"]I am a bit surprised how people seem to have more a problem with "dated sound" if it involves an "electric sound." Isn't all of the music by the Doors dated in sound? The music of Hendrix? The music of Zeppelin? [/quote]
Apologies, EQ -- I should have said "electronic," not "electric." (Les Paul on the brain.)
Entirely a taste thing, of course. For me, it's two-fold: the sound quality and the sound style. Remastering was a godsend for me because the tinny, flat sound quality of a lot of 60s and 70s recordings literally hurt my head, so I could only ever listen to the Doors, Hendrix, or Zeppelin for so long before needing to turn them off. But style-wise, I find that some (I wouldn't say all, but some) of their music is marked by their time period without being limited by it. Zeppelin's bluesy raunch, for example, plays better on modern radio than, say, Starland Vocal Band's "Afternoon Delight." (In a different vein, Simon & Garfunkel have more lasting appeal than Seals & Crofts.) The work tends to appeal despite changing times. (I think a lot of the Police transcends their time period as well.) And in my case, it's an overall style that I just like.
But to me much of The Equalizer sounds like a guy in the 80s on a Casio keyboard -- which isn't all that far off the mark. The sound quality isn't fabulous, but it's that thin, kinda plunky, and artificial electronic sound of the instrument(s) and some of the style that to me sticks it in its decade. I didn't much like that guy-in-the-80s-on-a-Casio-keyboard sound back in the 80s either. I fully admit that I am not in love with all works Copeland: Stewart and I have very different opinions, for example, on the relative import of lilting soprano sax and clarinet melodies. I understand the appeal to others, of course; just doesn't float my boat. As is, in 2009, I just don't think it holds up well.
Putting the tunes in the hands of separate, "real" (if you will) instruments does help, though. There are some interesting turns and melodies going on behind it all, and I do find it interesting to look at how Stewart's work has progressed. I'd be curious as all hell to hear a modern Equalizer set revamped for full orchestra.
[quote="sockii"]If/when I can get around to it, Tancred Ballet is actually one of the pieces which is in HB&CM as an instrumental interlude...I can probably extract that short section into mp3 for those who aren't, well, in the mood for 3+ hours of opera...[/quote]
I hadn't realized. Thanks, sock. Do you know which disc/track? (I can't remember, but I'm pretty sure our copies are from the same source.)
Dramatic highlights & a unique musical cosmos. Guaranteed.