by DirtyMartini on 29 Jul 2009 18:56
[quote="luddite lady"]Ha Ha! This is the kind of geeky dust up I love. First, thanks both of you for the hyphen. I totally forgot about that. Secondly, I can't be faulted too much for the apostrophe. I told you I was transported back to the eighties during their set. Leaving the apostrophe out would have been unauthentic. (Actually, I had no clue about the name change. Thanks for looking that one up.) But here's where the two of you are getting my pocket protector all twisted in a knot...I don't think the apostrophe is possessive. I think it is indicating a plural as it rightly does in words like TV's or VCR's. Doesn't the rule that applies to abbreviations also apply to numbers? For example, isn't it mp3's rather than mp3s? I'm more comfortable with the VCR example since I still have one of those but have remained mp3-free. And what if I was writing this before 2008? Would it be the B-52's' set, after all?[/quote]
HAHA.
Someone with a Strunk & White nearby will have to speak for them; I've just got Chicago right now and am working from style guide memory.
Llady, according to the CMOS, "capital letters used as words, abbreviations that contain no interior periods, and numerals used as nouns form the plural by adding s." Apostrophe-s is used to make a noun plural when the absence of an apostrophe would make for misunderstanding, such as in the case of individual lowercase letters and odd abbreviations/initialisms (such as M.D.'s, which can also be written without the periods as MDs).
So like Schmaff said, it's CDs, DVDs, VCRs, etc., NOT CD's, DVD's, VCR's. You would also learn your ABCs, but, because ps and qs are confusing, you would mind your p's and q's (or Ps and Qs, but I've seen that one vary).
In the case of B-52 with its terminal numeral, there is no confusion caused by a simple s. The original apostrophe-s was meant to suggest plurality rather than possession, but the apostrophe was extraneous; you can simply buy mp3s of the B-52s, a band that was formed in the 1970s.
Yep, before the name change, it would have been the B-52's' set (some might even say the B-52's's set, but they just need to be put down), which I can imagine was part of the reason they finally changed it.
Dramatic highlights & a unique musical cosmos. Guaranteed.