Honestly? I just don't get what all the hubbub is about. Look at it this way: The $100 membership over at TPT.com is for an entire year. Do people really think there won't be news and information over there that's worth reading for a measly $8.50 or so per month? I'll grant you there are some free forums - this one and some others - that will have good information as well, but I guess I just don't think that cost is wildly unreasonable. Maybe the management should consider letting people join on a subscription basis for $8.50 per month - something that's incredibly easy to set up using Paypal. Might make it easier on some younger fans and help tamp down the complaining somewhat.
All that said, the fine print probably ought to make it very clear that joining the fan club won't guarantee access to fabulous seats - as opposed to the existing verbiage promising priority before the public. It appears that scalpers certainly have had the advantage here, which technically means non-fan-club people got priority, for whatever reason.
I agree with ceebab on the unrealistic expectations, tho. I realize others may disagree with my assessment, here, but NYC is the wealthiest city on earth with the highest proportion of music fans. Did people really think they'd just waltz right into this presale and get tickets on the front row without any kerfuffle whatsoever?
I'm trying not to make generalizations, but I can't help but wonder what's going on - are people in that area so spoiled by having every act on earth play in their city that it never occurs to them to simply buy a plane ticket to some venue that's less in demand? Someone straighten me out, here.
I do think that opening the first presale only to people who were existing Best Buy members was not a great idea (and I say that as a pre-existing Best Buy member). It made people angry for no good reason, and Best Buy missed a great opportunity to add legions of people to their membership club. I can see their wanting to give people some kind of special privilege in exchange for having sponsored this tour, but it should have been something like downloads of new material, or free DVDs or posters or something - not first crack at the first publicly available concert tickets in 23 years.
All that said, though, we don't know if Best Buy folks will get first dibs on *every* presale, or simply this first one. I think letting the TPT.com fan club have the first presale date on the next round of sales might be a good idea. Management could even alternate the initial presales for different rounds of dates - Best Buy gets this first presale, fan club gets the next one, then Best Buy - as long as they let people know well in advance which club will get which presale. That will doubtless spawn griping amongst people who don't want to have to travel and want to see The Police on X date at *their* venue. I do think some of those people need to get nice and friendly with the folks over at fliertalk.com and realize just how insanely easy it is to get to, say, Denver or New Orleans, if they can't get seats at some of the more in-demand big-city venues.
Heck, we've all been talking about doing just that for weeks over here at SC.net...it's almost like some of our members are planning to follow them like the Grateful Dead! (wouldn't that be a kick? If I didn't have other responsibilities I'd do it myself!
)
Just some $.02.