Hmmm... let's see if I can remember, it's been a while.
I first heard the Police in late '79, when Regatta was released. It came out in October, the same month as my birthday, and I believe that I used my meager birthday money to buy the album. A nearby college station had played a couple tracks off of the album one evening, I think it was Message, and Regatta (the track), and both hooked me from first listen. I still remember hearing how great Regatta sounded, with its unique sparse sound (even on my crappy mono radio/tape player, stereo ones were still rather pricey in 1979). I was used to hearing stuff like Kansas, Journey, all those late 70s "FM-Rock" bands that were played incessantly, and The Police was a breath of fresh air.
I promptly went to my "local" record store. And by "local", that meant I had to take the Greyhound bus 20 miles over the hill to Santa Cruz, and hit up the record stores there. Although there was a few there, it was "Universes Imports" that really fed my habit. Over the years I would get most of my Police stuff there, from official LPs, to import 7", to my first live bootlegs on LP, to Police buttons/pins/stickers/banners, etc. That October, at the tender age of 12, I bought my first Police album, Regatta de Blanc. And once I could save up the money, I bought Outlandos, and I think a few buttons for my collection (which I still have).
One of the great things about Universes was that they would find unusual stuff related to bands and put it with the rest of their stuff. So I discovered and bought the Klark Kent album from The Police's section, as well as a KK single. I also got the Eberhard Schoener LPs he did with The Police, merely because the record store put a "features members of The Police" sticker on the front of the record. I also got Andy's solo stuff that way (w/Fripp).
Of course, this was well before MTV, as well as cable television in general, so seeing videos was rather uncommon where I was (One sidenote: it's really hard to explain to 'younger' people just how odd/different things were--at least in the U.S.--back before cable television and Mtv. You had American Bandstand on TV, AM Top-40 and FM "Rock" radio, and only if you were REALLY LUCKY, you were close to a college radio station that could/would play stuff that wasn't part of the AM/FM "format". Either that, or you lived in one of the big cities, like New York, Boston, or Los Angeles, and could hear "cutting edge" stuff.)
I do remember seeing "Don't Stand" on some sort of video show somewhere on broadcast TV, and that also coincided with seeing The Police showing up on the jukebox on the local Round Table Pizza (sound familiar, Nathan?
). I swear, I must have ruined that 7" because I must have played that single about 50 times, either with my friends, or family, or by myself after school, sitting there with a slice of pepperoni and a Pepsi. I was soooo into these guys that I wanted everyone to hear how great they were. Of course, looking back now, I realize that when Zenyatta came out, The Police were *really* breaking out all over, but at the time they seemed like a well-kept secret, that people who liked them were a special club, and when you heard one of their songs on the radio it was a special and exciting event.
I seem to be rambling a bit, and it's kinda strayed from the original "where did you first discover Stewart" thought of this thread. Suffice to say that I first discovered Stewart via the Police, and I've tried to keep up with all of the members over the past 30 years.
I have some other stories related to The Police and how they were a part of my youth, but I'll save them for another time I think.