Kali~
I'm gonna do my best at responding to this, while remaining coherent and not pissing off everyone involved.
How can one be a Sting fan? and a Stewart fan? I do it everyday. I love what they have each brought into my life and try not to look at their interaction with me as anything deeper than that. Meaning, I love their music. Sting's music, his lyrics, his style has influenced my life. I was born the year The Police began. When the guys went their seperate ways, Sting's solo work was more mainstream, it was more available. My first very own cassette, that was not a copy, was Dream of the Blue Turtles, given to me as a Christmas present from my big sister. I believe her words were, "Now you can keep your paws off my cassettes!" (It didn't stop me from snitching her Police cassettes every chance I got.
) Even when the boys seperated, Sting's music was consistently obtainable for me. Stewart's work is more obscure. My sister and I knew that he went into writing film scores, and classical composition but didn't know what or where. I didn't find out that stuff till the Reunion happened I found out that Stewart had his own site. Then I went looking. I discovered Stewart had been there all along, composing soundtracks to a lot of stuff I was comfortably enjoying. His influence was something I had taken for granted, but it was there, none the less. (Thank you, Stewart.) I can love them both for what they have both brought into my life, wonderful music, and a desire to be better, musically and intellectually.
As far as their looks and their bodies? I think they are both hot. I mean, come on. Sting is hot. Can't deny it. He's got great arms, gorgeous facial features (I love the cocked eyebrow thing too.), and I won't get started on his backside, but he is a nice package to look at. On the flip side of that, I can equally appreciate Stewart's look. The Man do look good in the green shorts.
And, there's a pic of him on a polo pony somewhere around that proves he's got just as admirable of a backside as Sting. He's lean, tall looks are not lost on me, and whether it be blond, brownish, or silver (oooh, shiny!) I adore the floppy hair. Yes, both men are handsome.
I don't know them personally, yet, and maybe one day, I will or I won't, but I won't judge their personalities until I've spoken with them. As far as egos go, they all have huge egos. I believe they all have said it before. I searched for this site to find out more about what Stewart's done since they broke up. I ventured into the forum and the, then little, group of people on here encouraged me to keep coming back, because they were the best bonded group of people I had yet seen on a board. I was truly persuaded to the "Stewart side" when I saw the tour announcement at the Whiskey (on youtube) and they showed Sting go straight into the Whiskey, Andy go straight into the Whiskey, and Stewart signing autographs and saying "keep 'em coming, keep 'em coming." My heart was stolen. That sealed it for me, it showed a sincerity in him towards his fans. On the other hand, I've not seen anything to discredit my appreciation for Sting either. For now, it's equal love, just in different ways.
God, I've gone on too long, should have hit the edit button a long time ago. I'm not trying to sway anyone to my way of thinking, everybody has their own opinions, but I did want to voice my opinion on the question you posed earlier.