I really liked Zodiac a lot. This was reviewed while Roger Ebert was on hiatus due to his illness. However, he has recently posted a late review. He gave it 4 out of 4 stars. I think he posted the review, even though it was late, because he thought it was so great. Roeper actually gave it four stars as well. Here is Roeper's review, if you care:
http://www.suntimes.com/entertainment/m ... 02.article
Roeper's comments regarding Downey are as follows:
"In a bit of casting so perfect it's almost distracting, Downey's Avery is a brilliant, rebellious, self-destructive manic-depressive drug addict/alcoholic who is his own worst enemy. (One could say Mr. Downey has spent much of the last, oh, 20 years researching the part.) Typecasting aside, Downey is amazing. Rarely has an actor been so comfortable playing someone who makes everyone around him extremely uncomfortable"
Mrs. EQ lived in Vallejo for awhile, so she found the movie to be unsettling.
Roeper was kind of dull on Leno without Roger.
There is no bigger gong.