by blueboy on 04 Feb 2007 10:22
That Spirits clip from Youtube is a perfect example of why Stewart ROCKS!
I like a lot of the drummers that Sting has worked with, but they just don't compare when doing Police tunes. There is another link to the '83 Montreal show when you play the link yobculture posted, and if you play it right after Sting's version, it is just so clear why the Police ROCKED! (Maybe that show wasn't Sting's best performance, but Stewart was great as usual)
Nobody touches Stewart for that dynamic sense of urgency and energy that he brings to the Police. It's not even close.
I have to admit though that I absolutely hated the "Synchronicity Concert" when it first came out because it didn't sound like "The Police" to me. The backing vocals were distracting, you couldn't hear Andy's guitar, the bass sound was kind of farty sounding, and the sequenced keyboards were kind of cheesy.
But over the years I have actually grown to like it, or at least not be offended by it.
I wouldn't have a problem if they found a really good guitarist/keyboard player with good "Sting-like" background vocals to fill out the sound live. As long as they are not a overbearing personality/presence on stage I think it would be OK.
Bottom line though is that it has to ROCK!!!