Divemistress of the Dark wrote:Not to rub salt in Kellie's wound, but they were one of the best live bands in the world.
I KNOW! Sadly video recordings, though evidential, just aren't the same.
What I definitely get, though, are preferences of certain eras/albums, dislikes of others.
Reveal I still abhor,
Monster I like on occasion but see as more of a reflection of its time.
New Adventures in Hi-Fi, however, though so very different from the reasons that I love REM, really caught me a year or so after it came out. "Undertow" and "Leave" are a couple of my favorite songs ever, despite being so divorced from amazing classics like "Finest Worksong" as to not even be comparable.
I think EQ's nailed it: "ETA - Clarification: I did not start to dislike REM because they were bad. Just that they became a different band from the one I loved. I know bands need to grow, but I guess they grew into a different direction than I was going in my life at that time."
New Adventures, for me, came at just the right time, despite being entirely the wrong sound for my comfortable memory.
Up wasn't quite right for me when it came out, but I found a place for it later.
Reveal, not so much.
Dramatic highlights & a unique musical cosmos. Guaranteed.